Verified Document

Systems Thinking And Transforming Higher Education Case Study

Systems Thinking Case Study: Karen Avery Q1. From a systems perspective, what factors do you believe contributed to the marginal results obtained by the various subgroups within the task forces?

According to Lunenberg (2010), schools are open systems although the degree to which they interact with the external environment may vary considerably, based upon the open-mindedness of administrators. The initial solutions offered by the task force reflected a closed mentality, in the manner in which they suggested options such as motivating teachers, total quality management, a return to basics, or other solutions which merely reconstituted previously-used and ineffectual frameworks (Razick & Swanson 2010). No input was solicited from the larger community in the other task force models until Avery intervened.

Q2. Identify and discuss instances of an aggregate mentality at work in this case.

An aggregate or community mentality suggests that the sum of an organization is more powerful than the components of its parts (Razick & Swanson 2010). The initial task force findings, however, proposed monitoring from within and focused on specific, individual components of school improvement rather than holistic, community-wide improvement of the school (Razick & Swanson 2010).

Q3. Would Karen today describer her school or school system as relatively open or relatively closed? Why? Classify the new model as open or closed. Why?

Today, after instituting her reforms, Karen Avery would likely describe her model as an open one. Avery’s model is centered upon making a good faith effort to have teachers act as guides, not disciplinarians, which disrupts the silo mentality of standardized education (Razick & Swanson 2010). Avery...

As noted by Lunenberg (2010), the inputs into any school system can roughly be classified as either “human resources, financial resources, physical resources,” or “information resources” and by bringing in parents and outside guides Avery’s reforms are clearly honoring this concept (p.2). By asking parents to choose which is most appropriate for their children in dialogue with school administrators, a new range of opinions and ideas can be infused into the system, thus hopefully improving the system’s outputs (Razick & Swanson 2010).
Q4. Discuss the feedback mechanisms that exist in the new school model.

What is particularly heartening about the new system is the consistency and variety of the feedback mechanisms which exist within it. First and foremost, teachers provide feedback to students as guides and mentors (Razick & Swanson 2010). But students similarly provide feedback about the extent to which the program is working to achieve mutually agreed-upon goals. Students working in groups also provide peer feedback. Teachers working in clusters of three to six guides provide feedback to fellow teachers and parents likewise provide input about the program (Razick & Swanson 2010). Feedback, in short, is constant. “Feedback is crucial to the success of the school operation. Negative feedback, for example, can be used to correct deficiencies in the transformation process or the inputs or both, which in turn will have an effect on the school's future outputs” (Lunenberg, 2010, p.3).

Q5. Does the new school model appear to invite chaos or amplify variety? Discuss why.

The new…

Sources used in this document:

Reference

Lunenburg, F. (2010). Schools as open systems. Schooling, 1(1), 1-5. Retrieved from: http://www.nationalforum.com/Electronic%20Journal%20Volumes/Lununburg,%20Fred%20C.%20Schools%20as%20Open%20Systems%20Schooling%20V1%20N1%202010. pdf

Razik, T. & Swanson, A. (2010). Fundamental concepts of educational leadership and Management (3rd ed.). New York, NY: Pearson.


Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Education Review It Is Now
Words: 4295 Length: 14 Document Type: Term Paper

It is now recognized that individuals learn in different ways -- they perceive and process information in various ways. The learning styles theory suggests that the way that children acquire information has more to do with whether the educational experience is slanted toward their specific style of learning than their intelligence. The foundation of the learning styles methodology is based in the classification of psychological types. The research demonstrates that,

Education Need for Study Roles and Responsibilities
Words: 4083 Length: 15 Document Type: Term Paper

Education Need for Study Roles and Responsibilities of Assistant Principals Historical Perspective of Assistant Principal Roles Prior and Current Research Studies of Assistant Principal Roles Assistant Principals and Use of Instructional Leadership Transforming Assistant Principals into Instructional Leaders: Key Obstacles General consensus indicates that the role of the assistant principals should move beyond its traditional clerical and disciplinary heritage to evolve to instructional leaders that deal with curriculum development, teacher and instructional effectiveness, clinical supervision, staff development

Social Trends in Education the Next 5 Years
Words: 1937 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Social trends in Education / the next 5 years With societal establishments and school structures, we can carry the most important task of providing youths with the necessary education which will provide them opportunities to thrive in our community. A simple casual glance at the comparative mode of lifestyle in our country would make it obvious that these establishments performed in an excellent manner for the greater part of this century.

Rethinking Curriculum in Education for
Words: 3030 Length: 10 Document Type: Assessment

253). Based on their review of 20 existing education for sustainability initiatives, Ferreira and her associates identified three primary models that exist along a continuum from local to more broad-based approaches as follows: 1. Collaborative Resource Development and Adaptation model: This model seeks to bring about change through the development and adaptation of high quality curriculum and pedagogy resources. It does not usually seek to bring about change across a

Issues Faced by Education in the 21st Century
Words: 2426 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Introduction Over the decades, there has been significant advancement and progression in education. With such progression comes the incessantly mounting necessities for education to guarantee student and teacher engagement and provide learning prospects for the present-day students. This paper examined the prevailing issues faced by education in the 21st Century. Specifically, the paper will extensively examine issues about the use of technology, the role of teacher educators, student needs and abilities,

Research Report on Education in the United States
Words: 2374 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

“Why school?Education has become a very contentious and polarizing issue throughout the United States. Here, the subject of schooling, and the dynamic changes occurring in the industry, have resulted in antagonistic and vigorous debate. Arguments have taken a litany of forms ranging from teacher pay and benefits, to proper testing of students. Others have questioned the education model of the United States and have proposed a more comprehensive and interconnected

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now